"Virginia Reel" by David St. John
Clocking in at 7 pages, this is the longest poem in the collection so far, and it reads like a story. The lack of commas slowed me on the first couple readings, but when I read it like a run-on sentence, I was able to make better sense of it.
The first thing it made me think of was "The Devil Went Down to Georgia" by the Charlie Daniels Band. The poem is set in the south, and the main characters are a father and daughter who both play fiddle in a way that others describe as "touched by the Lord / Or the Devil I don't really know which anymore."
The narrator wants to learn to play fiddle from the father and then begins to learn from the daughter, as well. At the end of the poem, the daughter and the narrator play together as the father holds "His annual celebration to commemorate his favorite sorrows." The father "began to rise imperceptibly lifting up beyond the dock ... dancing just above the water twisting while slowing rising higher within the air & drifting farther away." Virginia (the daughter) continues to play, then leaves him suspended above the quarry blocks, until presumably, he falls to his death.
This is a pretty dark poem, and there are only a few songs from Taylor Swift's catalog that seem like they could align - "ivy," "no body, no crime," and "Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?"
For "ivy" (insert plug for one of my favorite songs of her whole catalog here), it's a section of the middle of the poem:
[...] I told her Well one day last week Lucas
Came up here & sitting just where you're sitting told me
I'd better watch myself & he pointed to those
Virginia creeper vines crawling up the trunks & along
the branches of every tree on this hillside
Slowly strangling the whole tree & covering every single
inch with their embrace & he said that was you
Virginia & your vines came from your genius & your mind
& they'd find their way up my body & finally
Into my own mind where they would choke every hope or
dream I might have until a redtail's screech
Floats at night over the James & nobody'd every hear of me
& I'd be just another meal of a Virginia creeper
This is making it so very difficult to decide, because I think that section is a perfect response to "ivy":
Oh, goddamn
My pain fits in the palm of your freezing hand
Taking mine, but it's been promised to another
Oh, I can't
Stop you putting roots in my dreamland
My house of stone, your ivy grows
And now I'm covered in you
Full disclosure, I wasn't intending on picking "ivy," but I might have convinced myself otherwise.
"no body, no crime" is a little bit more on-the-nose, as the song is a story about a woman who has a friend who is killed by her husband. He successfully covers up the murder, but the friend knows he did it but "just can't prove it," and she won't let up until the day she dies. The friend eventually murders the husband of her friend in revenge and frames his mistress for his murder. In both the story and the poem, there are murders but no bodies, but I think that's about as close as they get. The poem is about a daughter killing her abusive father, and the song is about a friend getting revenge on the murderous husband of her friend.
I had thought that I had settled on "Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?" and I may still end up there, now that I'm spotting more and more threads. The first might be a bit of a stretch, but it's a possibility. At the time the song came out, I felt like I was one of the few Swifties who had knowledge of "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?" a play that was eventually adapted as a film starring none other than Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton ("Burton to this Taylor" reference in "...Ready for It?" anyone?). All that to say, the play on "Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?" from "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?" seems to be a thread in the poem because the daughter's name is...Virginia. In the song, the narrator leaps from the gallows and levitates down your street. In the poem, the father ends up levitating above the river until meeting his death. There are tones of possession in "Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?" especially if you take into account the final screen when Taylor performed the song during the Eras Tour - there was a filter that made her skin begin to look old (dead?) and her eyes turn completely white. Throughout the poem, there are references to Virginia being possessed by the Devil. Both poem and song also give power to their female leads, allowing them to exact revenge on those that have wronged them.
So, I did it. I convinced myself that it's "Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?"